Searching for the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island? Don’t worry; we’ve got you covered! From beachfront eateries to upscale bistros, this gem of a destination offers a plethora of culinary adventures that cater to every palate. With its gorgeous views and vibrant dining scene, the island offers a diverse array of restaurants, each with its own unique charm and tasty menus. After a day filled with trying various dishes, head back to your Anna Maria Island vacation rental with Fran Maxon for the ultimate vacation experience.
From fresh seafood to elegant dining experiences, here are some of the top restaurants that you should definitely explore during your visit to Anna Maria Island.
The Ugly Grouper
Come experience the vibrant atmosphere of The Ugly Grouper, your go-to spot on AMI! Indulge in fresh local seafood and refreshing beverages while soaking up the beach atmosphere at this outdoor dining venue.
The Ugly Grouper specializes in fresh, locally sourced seafood, offering a menu that’s as creative as it is delicious. Their signature dish, the Grouper Tacos, is a must-try, featuring perfectly seasoned and grilled grouper fillets topped with a zesty slaw and a drizzle of their house-made sauce. If you’re in the mood for something a bit heartier, the Ugly Grouper Sandwich never disappoints—it’s a fan-favorite that pairs beautifully with one of their craft beers or specialty cocktails. Bring along the whole family, including your furry friends, as they welcome everyone. Plus, enjoy entertaining activities like cornhole and catch your favorite sports games on their nine TVs!
Blue Marlin Seafood
Located on historic Bridge Street, The Blue Marlin offers a dining experience that combines the charm of old Florida with modern, mouthwatering seafood dishes. Housed in a quaint 1920s cottage, the restaurant is known for its cozy ambiance, complete with reclaimed wood and nautical accents, creating the perfect seaside vibe.
The menu features an array of freshly caught Gulf seafood, including blackened grouper, shrimp and grits, and crab cakes that are as fresh as they are flavorful. For those seeking something a little different, the Blue Marlin also serves tender steaks, seasonal vegetable dishes, and so much more!
The Porch Restaurant Anna Maria
At The Porch Restaurant, they have many incredible meals, from signature dishes, seasonal entrées, specialty spritzers, top-quality steak, fresh fish, and a vast selection of beer and wine to choose from. Everything you will explore on this menu is made fresh, from scratch, and in-house. Each dish is carefully prepared with the freshest ingredients, and there is something everyone in your group will love. Start off with their Cajun Shrimp and Crab Dip served with Naan and Crostinis. For the main course, try their Sherry Chicken, made with a sherry cream sauce, marinated chicken breast, and your choice of freshly made sides.
The Waterfront Restaurant
Experience The Waterfront Restaurant, one of the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island. Their regular menu is based on the finest products they can find and is updated seasonally. Start off with their Baked Brie appetizer, made with phyllo-wrapped brie, honey, toasted almonds, grapes, apples, and crackers. For the main course, try their Scallops & Pork Belly Fried Rice, made with diver scallops, Gochujang-marinated pork belly, house-made kimchi, and jasmine fried rice. Pair this with their rick Hook & Ladder Chardonnay, Russian River Valley from Sonoma, California!
Ginny’s & Jane E’s Cafe
An ever-changing menu awaits you at Ginny’s & Jane E’s Cafe, featuring a mix of classic dishes and seasonal options. Indulge in a variety of offerings such as sandwiches, salads, soups, and quiches. If you’re in a hurry, their bakery cabinet is stocked with decadent cinnamon buns, freshly-baked muffins, cookies, and scones.
Don’t miss the chance to try their delightful Cream Brulee French toast for breakfast or savor the flavors of their Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich for lunch. Pair these with your favorite coffee beverage; Ginny’s serves everything from lattes to americanos.
Hurricane Hanks
At Hurricane Hanks, prepare to be wowed by fresh and elegant dishes made with five-star ingredients. Their menu includes a tasty selection of seafood, steak, pasta, salads, burgers, and sandwiches. Sit back, relax, and enjoy exceptional service while indulging in their high-quality cuisine. Start your meal with their irresistible Potato Skins topped with cheddar jack cheese, applewood smoked bacon, scallions, and sour cream. For the main course, treat yourself to the Maple Orange Salmon, expertly prepared and topped with maple, almond, and orange zest compound butter. Pair this dish perfectly with their Envious Old Fashion, made with Angels Envy Bourbon, angostura bitters, simple syrup, an orange peel, and a Filthy black cherry garnish.
Isola Bella Italian Eatery
Tucked away in a quiet spot on Anna Maria Island, Isola Bella Italian Eatery offers a true taste of Italy in a cozy, inviting setting. Known for its freshly made pasta and authentic dishes, the restaurant serves favorites like fettuccine alfredo, lasagna, and seafood specialties such as shrimp scampi and linguine with clams, all crafted with high-quality ingredients.
With a charming indoor dining area and a lovely outdoor patio, Isola Bella is the perfect spot for a romantic meal or a casual dinner with family and friends. Finish your meal with a classic tiramisu or creamy gelato, and enjoy the warmth of Italian hospitality right here on the island.
Bridge Street Bistro
Located on Bradenton Beach, the Bridge Street Bistro offers a dining experience with spectacular views of the beach and the Gulf of Mexico. The atmosphere is relaxed yet refined, perfect for a casual dining experience. Dine al fresco on the third-floor terrace and relish the breathtaking sunsets while enjoying expertly prepared cuisine at reasonable prices. Start your meal with their Truffle Parmesan Fries, infused with truffle oil and parmesan cheese and topped with parmesan lime aioli and scallions. Indulge in their Bistro Steak Burger for dinner, featuring a ground steak blend, bacon jam, and classic burger toppings. Finish off your Bridge Street Bistro dining experience with their detectable Flourless Chocolate Tart.
Plan Your Visit
Discover the perfect beach getaway with Fran Maxon Real Estate’s Anna Maria Island vacation rentals. Browse our selection today and book your dream vacation on the stunning shores of this Florida gem!
Sandbar Seafood & Spirits
For a memorable dining experience with your toes in the sand and stunning beachfront views, head to Sandbar Seafood & Spirits. Enjoy the family-friendly atmosphere and create unforgettable memories as you dine with a backdrop of brilliant sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico. Kickstart your meal with their Crispy Brussels sprouts drizzled with sweet ginger soy sauce, toasted sesame seeds, and green onion. For the main course, don’t miss their Stuffed Shrimp, stuffed with crabmeat and served with Bahamian rice, farm vegetables, and a flavorful beurre blanc sauce. Pair this dish with their Bourbon Smash, a popular cocktail made with bourbon, simple syrup, and muddled mint and lemon.
Book Your Anna Maria Island Vacation Rental with Fran Maxon Real Estate
While indulging in the culinary delights of Anna Maria Island, ensure that your accommodations match the island’s charm and splendor. Fran Maxon Real Estate offers a superb selection of Anna Maria Island vacation rentals, including beachfront properties that allow you to experience the island’s allure to the fullest. Whether you seek a spacious Anna Maria Island beachfront rental or a cozy condo with panoramic views, Fran Maxon Real Estate can help you find the perfect vacation rental for an unforgettable island retreat.
Each of our rentals offers amenities such as fully equipped kitchens, spacious living areas, and so much more, all just steps away from AMI’s pristine beaches. Don’t just take our word for it. Book your stay in one of our amazing Anna Maria Island rentals and create memories that will last a lifetime with us today!
