A day on Anna Maria Island often ends the same way—sand on your feet, sun on your shoulders, and a craving for something cold and sweet. When you’re staying in one of our Anna Maria Island vacation rentals, finding the right ice cream spot adds a simple but memorable highlight to your trip. From classic scoops to creative treats, the island offers a variety of locally loved options.
Here are some of our favorite places to enjoy ice cream on Anna Maria Island.
Small Town Creamery
Small Town Creamery is a go-to stop for families. Located in Holmes Beach, this shop serves Amish-style ice cream known for its rich texture and traditional flavors. Portions are generous, and the relaxed setting makes it easy to stop in after a beach day. It’s a dependable choice for anyone who enjoys classic ice cream done well.
Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff
Holy Cow offers a fun mix of ice cream and gifts, making it a hit with both kids and adults. The shop is bright and welcoming, with a rotating selection of flavors. Its central location makes it a convenient stop while exploring shops or enjoying Anna Maria Island dining nearby.
Two Scoops
Two Scoops in Anna Maria City is one of the most recognized ice cream spots on the island. With its old-school charm, it’s a great place to slow down and enjoy the moment. Located near the City Pier, it’s perfect for grabbing a cone and taking a short walk to the water.
Dips Ice Cream
Dips Ice Cream is known for its soft-serve and creative combinations. It’s a casual stop where you can customize your dessert just the way you like it. This is a great option for families looking for something quick and satisfying.
The Laughing Flamingo Cafe
The Laughing Flamingo Cafe brings a unique twist by combining light café fare with homemade ice cream. It’s a smaller spot with a friendly, local feel. It’s a nice choice if you want a relaxed break during your day.
Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream
Tyler’s has been a staple on Anna Maria Island for years. Known for its wide selection, it offers something for everyone. It’s especially popular in the evening, when families gather after a full day on the beach.
Plan Your Visit!
Ready to experience all the delicious treats on Anna Maria Island? View our rentals, book your favorite, and prepare to make lifelong memories with the ones you love most!
Wicked Awesome Ice Cream Emporium
Wicked Awesome Ice Cream Emporium stands out for its bold flavors and playful presentation. The shop embraces a fun atmosphere with creative menu options. If you’re looking to try something a little different, this is a great stop.
Final Thoughts
Ice cream on Anna Maria Island is more than just dessert—it’s part of the experience. Each shop offers its own style, from classic scoops to creative treats. No matter where you go, you’ll find friendly service and flavors that fit the relaxed pace of island life. Adding a stop for ice cream is one of the easiest ways to make your trip feel complete.
Book Your Anna Maria Island Vacation Rental with Fran Maxon Real Estate
After a day of exploring ice cream shops and enjoying the beach, having the right place to unwind matters. At Fran Maxon Real Estate, we specialize in helping guests find the perfect Anna Maria Island rental for their stay.
Our team takes a personalized approach, ensuring your vacation home fits your needs—whether you’re traveling as a couple or with family. From comfortable spaces to convenient locations, we’re here to make your time on Anna Maria Island smooth and enjoyable.
