When you think of a perfect vacation spot, pristine beaches, vibrant nightlife, and exceptional dining come to mind. Anna Maria Island in Florida ticks all these boxes and more. From its enchanting sunsets to its welcoming community, AMI is a haven for those seeking a memorable getaway. One of the island’s standout features is its bars and restaurants, offering something for every palate. In this blog post, we will explore some of the must-visit Anna Maria Island spots, ensuring your nights are as exciting as your days.
Whether you are spending the evening tasting fresh seafood, enjoying handcrafted cocktails, or mingling with locals at an amiable sports bar, the island’s diverse bar scene will leave you wanting more.
Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier
A favorite amongst AMI bars, the Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier offers more than just a drink; it offers an unforgettable dining experience. The atmosphere you experience in any Anna Maria Oyster Bar comes from the warm smiles and genuine gratitude of the friendly and loyal staff. Starting your evening here is a surefire way to make it special. Start with their Grouper Bites, made with crispy, golden-brown bites of fresh grouper and served with the zesty Kaboom sauce for the perfect kick. For the main course, their Baja Tacos are a must-try. These tacos are loaded with crispy fish, cabbage, pickled red onions, and jalapeño and topped with Baja crema, combining to create a flavorful explosion in every bite.
Daiquiri Deck
Built to be an oasis for good times and great vibes, Daiquiri Deck is another enticing spot on Anna Maria Island. Famous for its vibrant and friendly atmosphere, this bar guarantees an experience you’ll want to share with friends. To kick off your evening, try their Conch Fritters, made with fried Conch, peppers, and onions, perfectly complemented by an orange habanero remoulade. The main course, Lobster Pasta, consists of succulent lobster, shiitake mushrooms, Marsala cream, arugula, Parmesan, and pappardelle pasta. The blend of rich, creamy flavors is nothing short of divine. Daiquiri Deck’s ambiance, excellent service, and top-tier menu make it one of the best restaurants in Anna Maria Island to spend your evening on the island.
The Doctor’s Office
A celebration of the best resources from American ranchlands and fresh Gulf Coast seafood, The Doctor’s Office is a must-visit for anyone looking for culinary sophistication paired with expertly crafted cocktails. Start your evening with their Smoked Old Fashioned—it sets the tone for an extraordinary dining experience. For your meal, their “World’s Best Smoked Salmon” is not to be missed. Crafted with Willie Krauch’s renowned smoked salmon from Comeauville, Nova Scotia, it is served with house focaccia, crème fraîche, and capers, completing the dish with elegance and flair. The Doctor’s Office knows how to combine fresh, exquisite ingredients to make each dish a celebration of flavor, making it a standout in the ami bars scene.
Bortell’s Lounge
For those who enjoy a more laid-back and sports-centric atmosphere, Bortell’s Lounge is the place to be. It’s where the locals love to go, and that speaks volumes about its allure. This great sports bar serves up fantastic food that matches its spirited atmosphere. The highlight here is their pizza—whether you opt for the classic styles or try something more adventurous like their BBQ chicken pizza, you’re in for a treat. Of course, you can always build your own pizza to suit your particular tastes. A visit to Bortell’s Lounge guarantees a relaxed evening with great food and drinks, ideal for making new friends and enjoying the game.
The Waterfront Restaurant Bar
The Waterfront Restaurant Bar distinguishes itself with a menu based on the finest, freshest products, updated seasonally to ensure the utmost quality. Their dishes are prepared in classic form, emphasizing natural, vivid flavors. To start, their Fried Queso Blanco is a unique and delightful appetizer made with hand-breaded Mexican queso blanco, complemented by a cilantro mojo sauce and a drizzle of chili orange Jarritos reduction. For the main course, the Frutti di Mare is a seafood lover’s dream, featuring diver scallops, shrimp, mussels, and clams tossed with garlic, olive oil, tomatoes, and basil served on linguini. The Waterfront Restaurant truly embodies the essence of refined dining on Anna Maria Island.
Plan Your Visit
Book your Anna Maria Island vacation rental with Fran Maxon Real Estate for an unforgettable stay. With a variety of beautiful homes offering easy beach access and breathtaking views, your perfect island escape awaits.
Book Your Anna Maria Island Rental with Fran Maxon Real Estate
To fully immerse yourself in the unique charm of Anna Maria Island, a comfortable and convenient stay is essential. Fran Maxon Real Estate offers a variety of Anna Maria Island vacation rentals that cater to different preferences and budgets. With their help, you can find the perfect Anna Maria Island rental to serve as your home base while you explore the island’s numerous delights. Whether it’s a cozy beachside cottage or a luxury oceanfront property, the right rental can significantly enhance your vacation experience, making every moment on AMI more enjoyable.
